Zarah Sultana, a former Labour MP, has ignited fresh debate by accusing Jeremy Corbyn of “capitulating” over the IHRA definition controversy during his leadership. The criticism comes weeks after the pair launched a new left-wing party opposing UK policy on Gaza.
Therefore, in an interview with the New Left Review, Sultana praised Corbyn’s mass appeal. However, she argued he made a “serious mistake” by accepting the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism. She claimed it wrongly conflates anti-Zionism with antisemitism.
“The movement was too conciliatory when attacked,” she said. “We must recognize that the state and media are our class enemies—you cannot give them an inch.” Her remarks quickly drew fierce backlash from Jewish organizations.
Furthermore, the Board of Deputies of British Jews called Sultana’s words “a grave insult,” stressing that the IHRA definition is widely supported by British Jews. Vice President Andrew Gilbert said it provides a “clear and measured” standard for identifying antisemitism.
Moreover, Labour Against Antisemitism co-director Alex Hearn dismissed Sultana as an “extremist.” He argued that rejecting the IHRA definition risks enabling harassment of Jews. He also disputed her claim that Kenneth Stern, a drafter of the definition, was its “lead author.”
The IHRA definition controversy played a major role in Corbyn’s downfall. In 2018, Labour adopted the definition after internal disputes. However, Corbyn later clashed with the Equality and Human Rights Commission over antisemitism findings.
After his suspension from Labour, Corbyn ran as an independent in 2024. A Labour source dismissed Sultana’s remarks, stating: “Keir Starmer rooted out antisemitism. Corbyn nearly destroyed the party—we’re not going back.”
Undeterred by criticism, Sultana posted on X, declaring herself a “proud anti-Zionist.” She accused the media of being “mouthpieces of the ruling class.” She challenged journalists to report her stance, linking it to Israel’s actions in Gaza.
The IHRA definition controversy continues to divide the left, with Sultana’s comments ensuring it remains a flashpoint in British politics. As her new party gains attention, the debate over antisemitism and free speech shows no signs of fading.
For more political updates, visit London Pulse News.
