A flawed domestic abuse screening tool is facing intense scrutiny. Consequently, the UK’s safeguarding minister has publicly admitted its failures. Minister Jess Phillips made this startling admission. Police and social workers use it widely. They rely on it to assess victim risk. However, it frequently misidentifies high-risk cases. Therefore, many victims do not get urgent support. This situation has had tragic consequences.
Authorities have used Dash since 2009. It includes twenty-seven questions for victims. For example, it asks if the abuse is getting worse. It also asks if the incident caused injury. Subsequently, a score determines the victim’s risk level. Unfortunately, this grading system is unreliable. Academics have raised concerns for years. Multiple studies confirm its inaccuracy. For instance, a 2020 London School of Economics study found alarming results. It analyzed Greater Manchester Police data.
Furthermore, a 2022 study reinforced these findings. Researchers from Manchester and Seville Universities analyzed data. They discovered ninety-six percent of high-risk victims were missed. Previously, Dash had graded them as standard or medium risk. Consequently, these victims did not receive intensive support. Sadly, some were later murdered. Now, their families are exploring legal action. They believe institutions failed their loved ones.
Minister Jess Phillips acknowledged the obvious problems. She said the tool simply doesn’t work. However, she also urged caution. She emphasized that change will not happen overnight. Meanwhile, practitioners must use the current system. Phillips also noted a critical point. Any risk assessment is only as good as the user. She said professional training is absolutely vital. Moreover, risk is dynamic and can change quickly.
The National Police Chiefs Council shares these concerns. In fact, it developed a new tool named Dara in 2022. Despite this, many forces still use the old system. Twenty out of thirty-nine police forces still use Dash. The council stated tools should not be used alone. Officers must also use their professional judgment.
Charities also criticize the flawed domestic abuse screening tool. Sistah Space works with black women. They say Dash misses cultural nuances and specifics. Often, their specialists identify high risk where Dash fails. The charity that created Dash, SafeLives, defended it. They called it simple, universal, and accessible. But they admit it needs updating. It also needs to be used correctly.
The government is now reviewing the entire system. The Home Office will publish a new strategy soon. Everyone agrees the current situation is unacceptable. This flawed domestic abuse screening toolmust be replaced. Ultimately, the goal is clear. We must better protect vulnerable victims from harm.
For more political updates, visit London Pulse News.
