The Scottish government has shelved two major legislative proposals related to Scottish equality legislation: a standalone misogyny law and a ban on conversion practices. They cited overwhelming legal complexities ahead of next year’s Holyrood elections. The decision marks a significant departure from Nicola Sturgeon’s progressive policy agenda. Additionally, it has drawn fierce criticism from equality campaigners. Scottish equality legislation is facing scrutiny over this decision.
Ministers had pledged to criminalize misogyny following a 2022 review by human rights expert Helena Kennedy. She warned that existing hate crime laws failed to address systemic gender-based hatred. Instead, the government now plans to introduce anti-misogyny measures through secondary legislation. Helena Kennedy previously dismissed this move as inadequate. Jamie Hepburn, Minister for Parliamentary Business, blamed recent UK Supreme Court rulings on gender definitions for complicating the legal framework. Issues with Scottish equality legislation have arisen from these complications.
Women’s rights groups reacted with dismay. “At a time of unprecedented misogyny, dropping this landmark bill is unbelievable,” said Sandy Brindley of Rape Crisis Scotland. The government also abandoned plans for a Scottish ban on conversion therapy. They opted to defer to UK-wide legislation—a disappointing outcome for those advocating for stronger Scottish equality legislation.
LGBTQ+ campaigners accused ministers of betrayal. End Conversion Therapy Scotland likened the decision to Thatcher-era anti-gay policies. They called it “a stab in the back” for queer communities. Equality Minister Kaukab Stewart insisted the government remains committed to banning conversion practices. However, she acknowledged the need for cross-border coordination. She emphasised the importance of robust Scottish equality legislation moving forward.
The retreat signals a strategic shift under First Minister John Swinney. The SNP is moving toward centrist policies after years of rights-focused reforms. As critics decry the delays, the government faces mounting pressure. They must prove their equality commitments extend beyond rhetoric. The evolution of Scottish equality legislation will be closely watched by stakeholders.
For more political updates, visit London Pulse News.
