The modest income tax pledge has ignited a fierce political battle. Kemi Badenoch and Sir Keir Starmer clashed over who should be shielded from tax hikes. Meanwhile, ministers remain tangled in confusion over the definition of “modest incomes.”
Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander first made the modest income tax pledge on Sunday. She vowed to protect working people from tax rises in the upcoming Budget. Since then, government officials have stumbled when pressed for details.
During Prime Minister’s Questions, Badenoch challenged Starmer to clarify the policy. She accused Labour of failing to explain who qualifies. Starmer fired back, defending his government’s economic record. He argued that the Conservatives left behind stagnant growth.
Labour’s manifesto promised to shield “working people” from tax increases. However, the term remains poorly defined. Last year, ministers gave conflicting answers about who fits the category. Now, Alexander’s latest remarks have deepened the uncertainty.
Starmer attempted to clarify his stance during the debate. He said the government prioritizes hardworking individuals without large savings. He highlighted the recent rise in the national living wage as proof of Labour’s commitment.
The government faces mounting pressure to raise taxes this autumn. Weak economic growth and reversed welfare cuts have strained finances. Despite this, ministers refuse to confirm specific tax policies ahead of the Budget.
Labour has ruled out hikes on income tax, VAT, and corporation tax. Yet, they face backlash over last year’s National Insurance increase. Now, speculation grows over possible threshold freezes or wealth taxes.
Badenoch also claimed Labour might tax pension contributions. She provided no evidence but used the accusation to attack Starmer’s credibility. Labour has not confirmed any such plans, leaving the claim unverified.
With the Budget months away, ministers brace for relentless questioning. Critics demand clear answers on the modest income tax pledge. Meanwhile, Labour backbenchers push for wealth taxes, adding to the tension.
As the debate rages, one thing is clear—voters want transparency. Until then, the modest income tax pledge will remain a contentious issue.
For more political updates, visit London Pulse News.
